Wed, 06 Nov 2013 05:30:00 GMT | By Sapa

Zapiro Hindu Cartoon Complaint Dismissed

A complaint about a Jonathan "Zapiro" Shapiro cartoon in the Sunday Times depicting the Hindu god of success, Lord Ganesha, was dismissed on Tuesday.


Lord Ganesha (© Wikimedia Commons\Murtikar chandulal verma)

A statue of Lord Ganesha

Press Ombudsman Johan Retief gave the newspaper the benefit of the doubt for exercising its right to freedom of expression.

"I eventually conclude that the cartoon was unfortunate and in bad taste, but that the offence that Hindus took to it did not outweigh Zapiro's right to freedom of expression, although he came dangerously close to breaching the [press] code," Retief said.

The cartoon shows the Hindu god holding a cricket bat and money while Cricket SA CEO Haroon Lorgat, tied up on an altar, is about to be stabbed as a sacrifice to him by two CSA officials. In the cartoon Lord Ganesha symbolises the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI).

This came after CSA had agreed to suspend Lorgat for the duration of India's tour to South Africa, following alleged pressure by the BCCI.

Retief said the complainants said the cartoon was disrespectful, insensitive, fallacious, disingenuous, and insulting as it trivialised and belittled Indian culture and religion. They said it exceeded the parameters of freedom of expression.

Some complainants said the cartoon misrepresented the situation between CSA and BCCI, while others argued that Hindus did not make sacrifices to Lord Ganesha as portrayed in the cartoon, and that the god had nothing to do with money.

President of the Universal Society of Hinduism, Rajan Zed, said Lord Ganesha was meant to be worshipped and not "thrown around loosely in re-imagined versions for dramatic effects or other agenda".

"Unnecessarily tying the deity with the BCCI... was highly inappropriate," he said.

The SA Hindu Dharma Sabha argued that the cartoon could fan the "flames of religious acrimony and division".

The organisation demanded an undertaking that Hindu symbols would not be used in cartoons in newspapers and magazines in future.

Sunday Times editor Phylicia Oppelt argued that the cartoon made no comment on Hinduism or Lord Ganesha, but merely depicted Ganesha as a symbol of the BCCI because of its strong association with India.

"The fact that Ganesha's headgear was labelled BCCI Indian Cricket, and he was holding a cricket bat and money, underscores the meaning the cartoonist sought to portray.

"To read the cartoon as an expression of disrespect to Hinduism is to misconstrue the point," she said in the newspaper's defence.

Sunday Times legal editor Susan Smuts said the newspaper would not apologise for the cartoon.

Shapiro explained that cartoonists did two kinds of cartoons involving religion -- some commented on a particular religious doctrine while others used religious iconography as a metaphor to comment on something else.

He argued that most readers would see it as metaphorical and not literal.

"The cartoon criticises the way the Indian cricket board... has bullied Cricket SA into sidelining... Lorgat.

"India is so closely associated with Hinduism that I feel the metaphor I have used will be broadly understood," Shapiro said.

In his ruling, Retief said he had weighed up Shapiro and the newspaper's right to freedom of expression against the offence that complainants took to the cartoon.

"The money and the cricket bat in Lord Ganesha's [hands] is not directed at the deity, but rather at CSA in the first place and secondly at the BCCI," he said.

"The perversion is not about Lord Ganesha, but rather about the adverse influence of money in the game of cricket; it is about how people religiously allow that influence to taint their decisions."

If the cartoon did ridicule the god it would have been an entirely different matter, Retief said.

After taking everything into consideration Retief said his mind was swayed towards the newspaper's right to freedom of expression.

He added: "A friendly word towards Zapiro and Sunday Times would be appropriate here: The cartoon came much closer to breaching the code than it appears to appreciate. In future, please proceed with caution."

top news

  • Parliament  Gallo Images

    Defence Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula told reporters that extra-ordinary measures have been put in place to prevent the EFF from causing another ‘chaos’ in Parliament, Sapa reported on Tuesday.

  • Julius Malema  Gallo Images

    Leader of the EFF Julius Malema would have breathed a sigh of relief this morning when the provisional sequestration order over his outstanding tax bill was extended to December 1.

  • Duduzane Zuma  Gallo Images

    Duduzane Zuma, the son of President Jacob Zuma, will appear at a formal inquest on Friday, at the Randburg Magistrate's Court, to determine if he was criminally responsible for the death of a young woman.

  • Jacob Zuma  Gallo Images

    The MPs were scheduled to spend a week in South Africa and meet with President Jacob Zuma and Baleka Mbete; however they cancelled their trip for fear of catching the deadly Ebola virus.

  • Thuli Madonsela  Gallp Images

    Public Protector Thuli Madonsela's letter to President Jacob Zuma this weekend has divided opinion and got many asking whether Zuma will ever be held responsible for any of the R246-million spent on upgrades to Nkandla.

  • People  Gallo Images

    Another earthquake hit Johannesburg in the early hours of Friday morning.

news features

Download Skype
Visit Now.co.za for more news on Now!